Appeals court has concerns over possible Gitmo video release


WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal appeals court expressed concerns Thursday about the prospect of ordering the Obama administration to release graphic videos of a former Guantanamo Bay inmate being force-fed during a hunger strike.

Judges hearing arguments in the long-running legal dispute considered whether any First Amendment interest in releasing the footage is outweighed by possible harm to national security.

The Associated Press and 15 other news organizations say the public has a constitutional right to see the videos.

Related: Torture pictures

The government says the tapes are classified and warns they could be used as propaganda by extremist groups to incite anti-American sentiment.

U.S. District Court Judge Gladys Kessler last year rejected the government’s concerns as vague and speculative. She ordered the videos released with redactions to protect the identities of U.S. personnel, but the release has been on hold pending appeal.

The three-judge appeals panel gave no obvious indication of how they would rule. But at times, they pressed lawyers on both sides over how much deference courts should give to the government’s interest in protecting national security.

The videos show former Guantanamo Bay prisoner Abu Wa’el Dhiab being forcibly removed from his cell, strapped to a restraining chair and force-fed his meals through a tube.

The Syrian native was held at Guantanamo for 12 years before being released in 2015 and resettled in Uruguay with five other detainees. During his last four years in detention, he joined other detainees in a hunger strike to protest their confinement. He tried to stop government officials from force-feeding him, a process he describes as torture.

Justice Department lawyer Catherine Dorsey told the judges the government had no expectation the videos would ever be made public when they were offered under seal as evidence in Dhiab’s civil case.

“There is no First Amendment right to these classified videos,” she said.

Even if the First Amendment comes into play, she said, national security concerns take precedence because the videos “can directly be used to incite violence.”

David Schulz, representing the media organizations, argued that the public has a significant interest in seeing the videos to know how the government is treating terror suspects held at the detention facility.

Related article: Guantanamo Bay staff sergeant claims three men believed to have committed suicide were actually tortured to death

Under the administration’s logic, Schulz said, the more objectionable the government’s conduct, the more likely government officials will argue it should be hidden from public view.

“That can’t be right,” he said.

Schulz also said the government had not offered a “logical and plausible basis” to show that disclosing the tapes would lead to violence against the nation.

But Judge Stephen Williams said the possibility of a violent response to the videos was only one of the government’s concerns. U.S. officials have also said disclosure could compromise prison security and endanger military personnel by encouraging other detainees to become uncooperative.

Judge Judith Rogers noted that lower courts often defer to the concerns of correctional officers in other cases and wondered why that wouldn’t apply here.

Schulz said the trial judge did give deference to the government’s concerns, but concluded it didn’t meet the standard of showing “serious damage” to national security.

Related article: WikiLeaks: "Detainees were raped" State Dept. cable

Dhiab has since begun another hunger strike in Uruguay and is demanding he be allowed to leave the South American country.

President Barack Obama indicated early in his presidency that he wanted to close the prison at Guantanamo, but he’s been blocked by Congress. Obama said Thursday he is not ready to concede that the facility will remain open when he leaves office.

The government has been steadily releasing prisoners and the Pentagon says 61 detainees now remain there.
Copyright 2016 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Speak truth to Power. JOIN the FIGHT -DONATE-

Do your part. Take two minutes, donate five dollars to keep this information online. We receive no government or corporate financing and could not continue this work without your support. Make an impact by making a one time donation now. Your tax deductible donation helps us provide you with content that you won't find anywhere else. Thank you for your support.

Related articles: Just a few bad apples...

Officer of the Year Arrested for Domestic Violence

Seven police officers to be charged in Oakland, California sex scandal
Anthony Police Officer arrested, accused of stealing money from VETS!!
Police Officer Arrested for Impregnating 14-Year-Old Girl he was suppose to mentor

Calif Police Officer Arrested For Domestic Violence

Update: Police officer arrested for domestic violence pleads not guilty

Cops Arrested for Domestic Violence

Prince William police officer charged in domestic assault

Pocahontas police officer charged with domestic assault

Gretna police officer arrested for battery, malfeasance

Two officers charged in Bay Area police sex crimes scandal

2 LAPD officers charged with covering up DUI crash, taking the driver home and filing false police report

FBI: Smugglers bribed U.S. customs officer at border with cash, sexual favors

Penns Grove cop charged with drug distribution, authorities say

Texas police officer, 3 others arrested in $150K cattle rustling ring

Dallas police officer arrested after allegedly choking girlfriend at Omni Hotel

N.J. police officer charged with soliciting prostitution while on duty

Police Officer Arrested By FBI For Smoking Crack On Duty

FBI Agent Arrested On UA Campus masturbating in woman's bathroom

Off-duty LAPD cop arrested for alleged lewd conduct in O.C.

Frederick County official spared jail time in Anne Arundel prostitution case

Shreveport Police officer arrested

Sheriff arrested for allegedly having sex with prisoner

California police officer arrested on suspicion of rape

Update: DOC: Prison guard accused of dealing heroin suspended

Update: N.Y.P.D. Commanders Are Arrested in Vast Corruption Case, Plead Not Guilty

Moss Point Officer Arrested On Meth Charge

Florida police officer arrested after soliciting $40 prostitute while on-duty

Indianapolis officer arrested on domestic violence charges

Police Officer Accused of Domestic Violence Shoots at Investigating Officer

Altamonte Springs police officer arrested on domestic battery charge

Lynchburg Police officer arrested for DUI, placed on paid administrative leave

Wife Beating Police Officer Apoligizes -To Get his Job Back: But Only Apologizes to fellow officers not...

Minnesota officer arrested for DWI goes on anti-police rant: ‘I f---ing hate the cops and I hate that I’m a cop!’

Who's the real criminal? Me (the citizens) or the police? Let's find out...

Pentagon: Hundreds of military kids sexually abused annually

How Police Policies Allow Domestic Violence Victims to be the Ones Arrested

Popular posts from this blog

Medical Marijuana Could Cost Big Pharma

Operation Bayonet: Inside the Sting That Hijacked an Entire Dark Web Drug Market

2Pac - Can't C Me (HD Video)